Flat rate vs reducing rate: why 12% can really mean 21%

Many small business loans are quoted as a flat rate. It sounds cheaper than a bank loan, but it is not. Here is the arithmetic, and how to compare any quote fairly.

In short

  • A flat rate is charged on the full loan for the whole tenure, even though you repay a bit every month.
  • On a 3-year loan, 12% flat is roughly 21% on a reducing balance; with a 1.5% fee it is about 22%.
  • Always convert a quote to an effective yearly rate before you compare it with another.

Two lenders quote you a ₹10 lakh loan for three years. One says 12 per cent. The other says 12 per cent flat. They sound identical. They are not even close, and the difference is thousands of rupees a month.

Two ways to charge interest

Reducing balance is how bank home loans and most formal business loans work. Interest each month is charged only on what you still owe. As you repay principal, the interest falls.

Flat rate charges interest on the original loan amount for the entire period, as if you hadn't repaid anything. You pay down the loan every month, but the interest calculation never notices.

The same loan, both ways

₹10 lakh for 36 months at "12%"
12% reducing12% flat
Monthly instalment₹33,214₹37,778
Total interest over 3 years₹1.96 lakh₹3.60 lakh
What the rate really is (reducing equivalent)12%about 21.2%

Flat interest is calculated as ₹10,00,000 × 12% × 3 years = ₹3.6 lakh, spread equally across 36 instalments. But the average amount you owe over the three years is roughly half of ₹10 lakh, so you are paying 12 per cent on money you've already returned.

A rough rule for converting

For loans of a few years, a flat rate is typically about 1.7 to 1.9 times the reducing-balance rate that gives the same payments. A 10 per cent flat quote works out to around 18 per cent on a reducing basis. A more precise number comes from solving for the rate that matches the instalment, which is what our loan true-cost calculator does.

Add the fees

Processing fees make it worse, because they are normally deducted upfront. On a ₹10 lakh loan with a 1.5 per cent fee (₹15,000), you receive ₹9.85 lakh but repay as if you had received ₹10 lakh.

QuoteEffective yearly rate (nominal)
12% flat, no fee21.2%
12% flat with 1.5% processing fee22.3%
10% flat, no fee17.9%
10% flat with 1.5% processing fee19.0%
₹10 lakh, 36 monthly instalments. Effective rate is the reducing-balance rate that equates what you receive with what you repay.

How to compare any two offers

  1. Ask each lender: Is this rate flat or reducing? Get the answer in writing.
  2. Note the amount you will actually receive after fees and insurance.
  3. Note the monthly instalment and the number of instalments.
  4. Convert both to an effective yearly rate with the same method.
  5. Compare the total you repay against what you receive, not against the sanctioned amount.

If a lender won't state the effective rate, work it out yourself from the instalment, which is a number they can't hide.

Is a flat-rate loan ever sensible?

Sometimes. If speed matters more than cost, if the loan is very short, or if the money earns far more than 20 per cent in your business, a flat-rate loan can still make sense. A short, cheap bridge for a clearly profitable order is a different thing from a three-year loan used to cover a structural loss. Just make the decision knowing the real number.

Questions worth asking every lender

What is the reducing-balance equivalent rate? What are all the fees, including GST on them? What are the foreclosure charges? What happens if an instalment is late? Is any insurance compulsory?

Numbers are computed for the stated example and rounded. Real quotes depend on the lender's method and may differ. This article is not a recommendation of any lender or product.

This guide is for general education and is not professional advice. Spotted a mistake or an out-of-date number? Tell us and we will check it.

One business-finance note, every other Friday.

Deadlines coming up, one idea worth acting on, and a number worth knowing. No product pitches. Unsubscribe whenever you like.